Hire against the current growth constraint. A product marketer may help when buyers do not understand the offer; a channel specialist may help when the offer works but distribution needs execution. A generalist needs clear priorities and support. If nobody can define the strategy, resolve that leadership gap before hiring someone to execute it.
Start with the job your customer needs done
The first-marketer conversation often starts with a channel: we need LinkedIn, we should run ads, we ought to publish more content. That makes the job description a list of outputs before anyone has identified the problem.
Start instead with what prevents a suitable customer from buying and succeeding. Are they unaware of the product? Unable to understand it? Unconvinced by the proof? Unable to get value after signing up?
Marketing may influence several of those stages, but one person should not inherit every unresolved business problem under a broad growth title.
Match the role to the constraint
If customers need extensive explanation and sales reinvents the pitch on each call, product marketing skills may be valuable. Look for customer research, positioning, messaging and sales-enablement work.
If the offer converts with a defined audience and a channel has shown promise, a specialist can deepen execution. Evaluate their ability to diagnose results, not just operate the platform.
If the company needs varied early work, a capable generalist may fit. Be explicit about the few areas that matter this quarter and the specialist support available. Generalist should describe range, not unlimited capacity.
If no one can choose the audience, offer or sequence, you may need senior direction first. That can be a bounded project or part-time leadership rather than a permanent executive hire.
Write a scorecard before the job description
Use a one-page scorecard with four sections:
- Outcome: what should be different in the business after the first quarter?
- Work: which recurring activities plausibly contribute to that outcome?
- Authority: what can this person decide without waiting for the founder?
- Support: which people, tools, budget and information will they have?
For a hypothetical B2B team, the outcome might be establishing a repeatable way to generate qualified conversations in one segment. That is still a hypothesis, not a guaranteed number. The work could include customer research, one distribution test and coordinating the follow-up process with sales.
It should not quietly include a brand redesign, three social platforms, paid media, event production and website development unless the company provides the capacity to support them.
Evaluate the thinking with relevant work
Ask candidates to explain a project resembling your current situation. What did they know at the start? What did they choose not to do? What changed their view? What did the result actually prove?
A short, bounded discussion of a fictional scenario can reveal how they work with incomplete information. If you request substantial bespoke work for your company, scope and compensate it appropriately.
Look for clarity about their own contribution. A person who worked inside a large, established team may have excellent skills without having built a function from zero. Both backgrounds can be useful; they solve different needs.
Onboarding is part of the hire
Provide access to customer language, previous tests, sales objections, product limits and the reasons behind earlier decisions. Introduce the people they will depend on. Agree a regular review that resolves decisions rather than simply collecting status updates.
If the hire keeps asking for direction, inspect the environment before concluding they lack initiative. Unwritten context and unclear authority make even capable people cautious.
My LinkedIn series examines this founder-dependence problem. The practical lesson is to hand over a defined responsibility with sufficient context, then judge the person against a realistic role.
Make the first hire a foundation
Your first marketer will influence how later work gets organised. Give them a role the company can learn from. A focused assignment exposes whether the strategy, channel and execution are working. An impossible assignment mainly reveals that one person cannot do everything at once.
First 10's fractional leadership work includes hiring plans, role specifications, interview scorecards and onboarding. The objective is a functioning team, with responsibilities that remain clear after the initial hire.
Apply this to your business
Collect five real tasks from the coming month. Which require a strategic decision, and which require daily production? Hire for the work that dominates.
Frequently asked questions
Should the first marketer be a generalist or a specialist?
Choose against the work that needs to change. A specialist fits a known channel or capability gap; a generalist fits a broader but manageable operating scope. Neither automatically supplies missing senior strategy.
How can a founder assess candidates fairly?
Use a realistic work discussion tied to the role's actual responsibilities. Ask how they would investigate the problem, what evidence they need and what they would deprioritise, rather than judging presentation polish alone.
Planning your first marketing hire?
Show Mohit the work waiting for the hire. He can help separate leadership, production and specialist needs before you write the role.
Talk through the problem ↗See how we could work together
