An ICP consultant should compare won, lost and stalled customers to identify the situations where your offer creates and captures value. The output should guide targeting, messaging and qualification, not merely list company sizes and job titles.
Start with outcomes, not an addressable-market slide
A wide market can contain few buyers who urgently need the product. Take a sample of won, lost and stalled accounts. Record the problem that triggered a search, the workaround in place, who sponsored the change, the buying constraints and what happened after purchase. Look for a pattern in urgency and ability to adopt, not just industry or revenue band.
Include customer success data. Some accounts close quickly but require heavy support or churn because the workflow never fits. A good ICP should predict value on both sides. If the product is new and customer history is sparse, interview prospects and document the uncertainty rather than treating a founder's intuition as proven segmentation.
Separate fit from reachability
An account can have the right problem but be hard to reach through available channels. Another may be reachable but lack budget or authority. Write both dimensions. For each candidate segment, assess pain, evidence of willingness to change, sales cycle, access, implementation burden and economic potential. This prevents a targeting exercise from becoming a list of impressive logos.
Map the roles involved: user, champion, buyer and gatekeeper. The person who searches may not sign. Note what each needs to believe. The ICP guide beyond firmographics shows how to describe those behaviours in a practical profile.
Make the output useful to teams
Ask the consultant for positive signals, disqualifiers, likely triggers, common objections, message angles and a small target-account sample. Apply it to CRM fields and lead qualification. Marketing should know what language to use; sales should know which accounts to prioritize and when to walk away. Avoid an elaborate persona document that no one uses.
Test the profile with a narrow campaign and an agreed review point. Record which accounts respond, qualify, progress and succeed. A single conversion rate is not enough when sales cycles differ. Update the ICP as products and markets change, but keep a versioned decision log so the team knows why the focus moved.
Scope the consultant's work
The project should include interviews or deal reviews, segmentation logic, a decision workshop and handoff to targeting and messaging. Ask what evidence will be available and what remains a hypothesis. If the company cannot choose a segment because of internal priorities, the consultant should surface that tradeoff for the founder rather than hide it in generic language.
Mohit's relevant experience: Data Sutram served several types of institutional buyer, which made focus and use-case clarity essential. Through Ten12 he has advised startups facing similar segmentation choices. First 10 brings that practical lens to ICP work. See the Data Sutram case and work history.
Apply this to your business
Ask the consultant to show positive fit signals and disqualifiers from real accounts, then apply them to one target list and one sales qualification form.
Frequently asked questions
How many customers do we need to define an ICP?
More evidence helps, but early teams can start with detailed interviews and deal reviews. Mark hypotheses clearly and revise them as new deals arrive.
Is an ICP just an industry and company-size filter?
No. Useful profiles include the trigger, problem severity, current alternative, decision process, ability to buy and signs that the customer will succeed.
Narrow the buyers worth pursuing
Bring a few wins, losses and stalled deals. Mohit can help find the pattern and turn it into a testable ICP.
Talk through the problem ↗See how we could work together
